Gated Communities, exclusive Roads and Public Services: a handy GuideA basic law city has actually exclusive regulate over its city streets, and private citizens can not restrict access to public roads; therefore, all roads in a gated neighborhood must be personal roads. The city can sell public streets to private interests through following details procedures. Once the roadways are private, however, the city cannot enforce traffic laws in the gated community, nor deserve to it usage public accumulation for any private purpose, together as road maintenance, rubbish collection, etc.

You are watching: Is a gated community considered private property

A basic law city must maintain the public highways within the boundaries and has exclusive regulate over the highways, streets, and also alleys of the municipality. The is particularly authorized to abate or remove an obstruction on that streets. Personal citizens may not block access to a public county road by the environment of a locked gate; therefore, to have actually a gated ar that restricts access to the public, all streets in the ar would necessarily need to be private.

But if the subdivision has previously been platted, climate all streets would have actually been dedicated to the city, therefore the city would have to convey the streets to the exclusive landowners the the ar (or the exclusive property owner’s association produced to regulate the gated community).

A general law or home rule city might by ordinance vacate, abandon, or close a city street in solution to a petition signed by all residential or commercial property owners abutting the street; however, the city might retain ownership of the street. The much more usual practice would be for the city to market the street, one of two people at fair market value or come abutting residential property owners. This procedure is administrate by Chapter 272 that the Texas Local government Code and is past the scope of this article.

Once the roads become private, the city’s duties and also powers v respect to the streets readjust dramatically. Cities might not force state or local traffic laws on privately-owned roadways within their boundaries. In addition, short article III, section 52 and also Article XI, ar 3 that Texas constitution prevent any type of city from lending credit, providing public money, or making any appropriation or donation to any type of private entity. In various other words, cities might not invest public money because that a personal purpose and also would therefore be prohibited native performing public services in the gated community, together as road maintenance, trash collection, etc. Ex parte Conger, 357 S.W.2d 740 (Tex. 1962); check out also Tex. Op. Att’y Gen. DM-13 (1991).

There space a couple of exception to this rules. Most notably, on petition the at the very least 25 percent that the building owners in a exclusive subdivision or on the request of the personal subdivision’s homeowner’s association, a city may prolong some or every one of its web traffic rules right into the private subdivision, in which situation the exclusive roads would be considered public for objectives of the traffic rules. The city would certainly charge the landowners or association a dues for offering these services.

With for to regulation enforcement, the Texas Penal Code defines a “public place” as any type of place to which the public or a substantial group of the public has accessibility and includes, but is not limited to, streets, highways, and the common locations of schools, hospitals, apartment houses, office buildings, transport facilities, and shops. In Woodruff v. State, 899 S.W.2d 443, 445-46 (Tex. App.–Austin 1995, no pet.), the defendant to be arrested for driving when intoxicated top top the grounds the Bergstrom Air force Base. The court held that Bergstrom was a windy place, also though it was fenced and the just entrance was with a guarded accessibility gate. Is a gated community a place where a “substantial group of the public” has actually access? The prize is unclear. Some city police departments may adopt a policy to respond to certain varieties of calls native gated communities, however not others. Again, the problem involves the delivery of public accumulation for personal purposes, i m sorry is prohibited by the Constitution and state law.

Although chapter 352 that the Texas Local federal government Code, which transaction with county fire protection, does not apply come municipalities, it might be instructive because that a city wishing to adopt rules and regulations for gated communities. A county has the government to regulate vehicular or pedestrian entrances in a gated ar “to guarantee reasonable accessibility for fire-fighting vehicles and equipment, emergency clinical services vehicles, and law enforcement officers.” A county might require a lockbox near and also within sight of the gate that have the right to be opened up manually. The county might require an authorized gate-operating device that will certainly activate the door on the sound of an emergency siren. The county may require at least one car gate be large enough because that emergency vehicles and at the very least one enntrance gate from the public best of way that is totally free of impeding obstacles. The county might require every residential structure in a gated community to have proper building identification that have the right to be seen by emergency responders.

See more: 2006 Pontiac G6 3.5 Firing Order, Pontiac G6 Gt: Spark Plug Firing Order

As you can see, gated communities create many legal and also practical concerns for both private landowners and also cities.